Most commercial Indian film-makers had always believed that the Indian audiences must leave their brains back at home to really enjoy their films. They actually wanted to convey that their films are about senseless entertainment. As Indian viewers got exposed to the content across the world, they were not willing to accept mediocre work anymore. So big film-makers of 80s and 90s who couldn't reinvent themselves became redundant. Subhash Ghai is the name that comes to mind almost instantly. He had made really successful films in his heydays. But as viewers' tastes changed, he couldn't learn the new grammar and tonality of film-making. On the other hand, Yash Chopra tried to keep up with a younger India and thus remained relevant. Though his later works weren't as powerful as his earlier films, he still managed to attract youngsters.
"Keep your brains at home" maxim is so well entrenched in our film-makers' minds that they don't trust the intelligence of audiences to understand things and thus they feel the need to spell out everything in their films. Of course it is not true for everyone. But this cliche is still dominant. Voice-over by a narrator in a film is a great technique to spell out everything for the audiences. It is necessary sometimes, when things happening on screen are too overwhelming or the material is too thick. Like in the Netflix series Narcos. The two cliches which are associated with voice-overs in India are:
"Keep your brains at home" maxim is so well entrenched in our film-makers' minds that they don't trust the intelligence of audiences to understand things and thus they feel the need to spell out everything in their films. Of course it is not true for everyone. But this cliche is still dominant. Voice-over by a narrator in a film is a great technique to spell out everything for the audiences. It is necessary sometimes, when things happening on screen are too overwhelming or the material is too thick. Like in the Netflix series Narcos. The two cliches which are associated with voice-overs in India are:
There is nothing wrong in it. But then it is a cliche and thus even at times when it doesn't work people stick to it. Viewers changed! Voice-over didn't!
I think when it comes to period films like Lagaan or Manikarnika, his voice-over is pitch perfect. Listen to his voice-over in Manikarnika and get mesmerized.
I think when it comes to period films like Lagaan or Manikarnika, his voice-over is pitch perfect. Listen to his voice-over in Manikarnika and get mesmerized.
But seemingly Bachchan has done voice-overs even for films like Hello Brother and Ra.One. There was nothing in those films to be really explained. They were senseless and they weren't even entertaining.
P.S. - In bad connectivity area today, so couldn't upload several other videos which I wanted to. Please bear.
--
My theme for this year's #AtoZchallenge is Hindi Film Industry / Bollywood cliches. You can read the theme reveal post here.
2017 Challenge Post from Letter V: VCR and Video Tapes - A post about two films I shouldn't have watched as a child. Click here to read.
2018 Challenge Post from Letter V: VCR and Video Tapes Part II - A post about three films that I watched on VCR several times. Click here to read.
2 comments:
Hello would you mind stating which blog platform you're using?
I'm looking to start my own blog in the near future but I'm having a difficult time
making a decision between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal.
The reason I ask is because your design and style seems
different then most blogs and I'm looking for something unique.
P.S Sorry for being off-topic but I had to ask!
Thanks for sharing. By the way, if you want to watch movies for free, here I found a post including several sites for help: Top 10 XMovies8 Alternative Sites
Post a Comment